
Photo: Timur Weber / Pexels
The right real estate agent can be the difference between a smooth sale and a stressful one — or between winning the home you want and losing it. To choose a Sioux Falls agent, interview more than one and compare their local track record, communication, and strategy rather than hiring whoever you met first.
Quick Answer: To choose a real estate agent in Sioux Falls, interview at least two or three before you commit. Pick the one with a strong local track record, clear and fast communication, and a specific plan for pricing your home or writing a winning offer. Confirm they’re a full-time, licensed agent who works your price range and area, check their recent reviews, and make sure the agreement terms and fees are spelled out in writing.
Why the agent you choose matters more in 2026
When homes sold in days and prices climbed every month, almost any agent looked good. The 2026 Sioux Falls market asks more of them. The latest Realtor Association of the Sioux Empire report (October 2026) shows a median sale price of $310,000, down about 4.6% from a year ago, homes averaging 83 days on the market, and sellers netting 96.8% of their original list price with roughly a four-month supply of homes. With mortgage rates back up to 7.28% for a 30-year loan as of mid-November, buyers are more careful and sellers can no longer count on the market to do the work.
In a market like this, pricing, preparation, and negotiation actually move the number on your closing statement. That’s exactly where a skilled local agent earns their fee — and where the wrong one can quietly cost you weeks on the market or thousands of dollars.
Interview more than one agent
Most people don’t. In the National Association of Realtors’ 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, roughly 74% of buyers hired the first agent they talked to, and the share of buyers and sellers using an agent hit a record high. Using an agent is clearly the norm — but hiring the very first one you meet, without comparison, is a gamble.
You don’t need to interview ten agents. Talking to two or three gives you a feel for who communicates clearly, who actually knows your neighborhood and price range, and who has a real strategy instead of a sales pitch. A good agent will welcome the question “why should we work with you?” and answer it with specifics.
What to look for in a Sioux Falls agent
A few things separate an agent who closes the deal from one who just opens doors:
- A real local track record. Ask how many homes they’ve helped buy or sell in Sioux Falls and the surrounding towns — Harrisburg, Tea, Brandon, Dell Rapids — and in your price range. Local comps and neighborhood knowledge are what price a home correctly and spot an overpriced one.
- Full-time and responsive. Real estate moves fast. An agent who answers texts and calls promptly can get your offer in first or handle an inspection issue before it becomes a dealbreaker. Ask how they’ll communicate and how quickly you can expect a reply.
- A pricing strategy you can see (sellers). A strong listing agent brings a written comparative market analysis and explains how they landed on a number — not just the highest figure to win your listing. Overpricing in a slower market is the fastest way to sit on the market and chase the price down later.
- Negotiation and process skill (buyers). Ask how they’d structure an offer at today’s prices, how they handle inspections and appraisals, and how they’ll protect your earnest money. In a market averaging 96.8% of list, the terms often matter as much as the price.
- A marketing plan (sellers). Professional photos, accurate MLS listing detail, and online exposure are the baseline. Ask to see how their current and recent listings look online.
- References and reviews. Read recent Google and Zillow reviews, and ask for a past client or two you can call. Patterns matter more than any single review.
- Licensed — and ideally a Realtor. Every agent in South Dakota must be licensed; you can verify any license through the South Dakota Real Estate Commission. An agent who is also a Realtor is a member of the National Association of Realtors and bound by its Code of Ethics.
Questions to ask before you hire
Bring these to any agent interview, whether you’re buying or selling:
- How many homes have you helped buy or sell in this area in the past year?
- Do you work in my price range and neighborhood regularly?
- How will you communicate with me, and how fast do you typically respond?
- If I’m selling: how will you price my home, and what’s your plan to market it?
- If I’m buying: how will you help me compete and protect me through inspection and appraisal?
- What are your fees, and what exactly does the agreement commit me to?
- Can I talk to a recent client?
Buyers vs. sellers: what to prioritize
If you’re buying, lean on availability, negotiation, and a strong lender network. Since the 2024 industry commission changes, buyers in South Dakota sign a written buyer-agency agreement before touring homes — so understand the term length and fee, and know they’re negotiable. A good buyer’s agent gets you in quickly, writes clean offers, and keeps a deal together through closing.
If you’re selling, prioritize pricing accuracy, preparation, and marketing. The agent who talks honestly about your home’s condition and the right list price — not just the highest number — is usually the one who nets you more. Ask how they’ll calculate your likely net proceeds after commission, the South Dakota transfer fee, title, and prorated taxes.
Red flags to watch for
Be cautious of an agent who only talks price and never strategy, who’s hard to reach during the interview (it rarely gets better later), who can’t point to recent local sales, or who pressures you to sign a long exclusive agreement on the spot. Promising the highest list price to win your business and then pushing cuts a few weeks later is a classic warning sign in a market like this one.
How we work at The Jeff Merrill Team
We’re a full-time, local team serving Sioux Falls and the surrounding communities for both buyers and sellers. Our approach is simple: honest pricing backed by real local comps, fast communication, and a clear plan from the first conversation through closing. If you’re deciding who to work with, we’re glad to walk you through how we’d handle your specific move — and happy to be one of the agents you interview.
Start your home search right now at siouxfallsgreathomes.com, or call The Jeff Merrill Team at (605) 413-7903 to talk through your buy or sell.
Frequently asked questions
Do you have to sign an agreement to work with a real estate agent in Sioux Falls?
To tour homes with a buyer’s agent in South Dakota, yes — since the 2024 commission changes, buyers sign a written buyer-agency agreement before showings. It can be limited in length and the fee is negotiable, so read it before you sign. Listing agreements for sellers are also written contracts with negotiable terms and length.
How much does a real estate agent cost in Sioux Falls?
Commissions are negotiable and set deal by deal, not fixed by law. Sellers commonly pay a total agent commission in the range of about 5% to 6% of the sale price, which may be split between the listing and buyer sides. Ask any agent to put their fee in writing and explain what it covers.
What’s the difference between a real estate agent and a Realtor?
Every Realtor is a licensed real estate agent, but not every agent is a Realtor. “Realtor” means the agent is a member of the National Association of Realtors and agrees to follow its Code of Ethics. In South Dakota, all agents must hold a license through the South Dakota Real Estate Commission regardless of membership.
Can you switch agents if it isn’t working out?
Sometimes, but it depends on the agreement you signed. Many buyer-agency and listing agreements can be ended early by talking to the agent’s managing broker, and some have a set term that simply expires. Read the cancellation terms before you sign, and raise concerns early rather than waiting.
How many real estate agents should you interview?
Two or three is plenty for most people. That’s enough to compare local experience, communication style, and strategy without dragging out your timeline. The goal isn’t to find a perfect score on paper — it’s to find the agent you trust to handle one of your largest financial decisions.
Sources
- Realtor Association of the Sioux Empire, October 2026 report (via SiouxFalls.Business): median price $310,000, 83 average days on market, 96.8% of list price, ~4.0 months of supply.
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, Nov. 19, 2026: 30-year fixed 7.28%, 15-year fixed 6.66%.
- National Association of Realtors, 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (agent-use and buyer-interview findings).
- South Dakota Real Estate Commission (agent licensing and verification).